Individual tax consultation

An individual tax consultation is an official clarification from the tax authority for a specific taxpayer regarding how to apply a provision of tax or other legislation controlled by the STS in their real situation. For business, this is not a "general certificate", but a tool for reducing risk where there is ambiguity: VAT, cash registers/software cash registers, excise duty, single tax, agency models, bonuses, marketplaces, imports, free transfers, mixed operations, e-commerce, withholding taxes from payments to individuals, and other issues where a mistake could end in additional charges. The ITC is provided free of charge, can be oral, paper, or electronic, but paper and electronic ITCs registered in the Unified Register primarily have practical protective value for business. (zp.tax.gov.ua)

What is an ITC and when is it truly needed

The Tax Code defines an ITC as an explanation from a controlling body provided to a taxpayer regarding the practical use of specific legislative norms, which is registered in the Unified Register of Individual Tax Consultations. That is, we are not talking about an abstract "explain the law", but about answering a specific question with specific factual circumstances. That is why requests where the business model, documents, sequence of operations are described and a clear tax question is formulated work best. (zp.tax.gov.ua)

It is appropriate to request an ITC when the law allows more than one interpretation or when you have an atypical operating model. For example: sales through a website and marketplaces, settlements through acquiring and cash on delivery, gift certificates, bonus programs, commission trade, agency agreements, sales of sets, free transfer, writing off losses, payments to non-residents, mixed VAT rates, excisable goods, cash registers/software cash registers in delivery, splitting business processes between a PE and a legal entity. In such situations, an ITC is often more useful than oral explanations from an accountant or a tax manager because it fixes the position of the authority in your case. (vin.tax.gov.ua)

What protection an ITC provides, and what it does not

For protection, it is important that the ITC is exactly in paper or electronic form and is registered in the Unified Register. The Tax Code directly classifies the actions of a taxpayer in accordance with such an ITC as circumstances that exempt from financial liability; penalties in such cases are not accrued, and already accrued ones are subject to cancellation. But this does not mean that the tax "disappears": the amount of the tax liability, if it is payable by law, will have to be paid. (zp.tax.gov.ua)

Therefore, an ITC is not a way to "legitimize" a risky scheme, but a way to reduce the risk of fines where the norm is not obvious. It will not help if the actual circumstances during an inspection turn out to be different from those you described in the request. Similarly, an ITC does not replace proper accounting, primary documents, correct application of cash registers/software cash registers, maintaining inventory records, licensing requirements, or compliance with rules on excisable products — it only answers questions of law within the competence of the STS. (Zir Tax)

Who provides ITCs and in what form

At the taxpayer's choice, an ITC can be oral, paper, or electronic. Oral consultations are provided by controlling bodies and state tax inspectorates. Paper and electronic ITCs are provided by controlling bodies defined by the Tax Code, except for state tax inspectorates. An important practical note: the STS contact center provides only unified answers, not ITCs. Therefore, for legal protection of business, you should focus exactly on a registered paper or electronic consultation. (vin.tax.gov.ua)

A paper or electronic ITC must strictly contain the title "individual tax consultation", a registration number in the Unified Register, a description of the questions raised taking into account factual circumstances, a justification for applying legislative norms, and a conclusion on the practical use of these norms. If you simply received a letter without such mandatory details, it is worth checking whether it is exactly an ITC and not a standard response to an appeal. (Zir Tax)

How to submit a request for an ITC

An appeal in paper or electronic form must contain: the name of the legal entity or full name of the individual, tax address, communication number and email address if any, EDRPOU code for a legal entity or RNTRC for an individual, and for persons who refused an RNTRC due to religious beliefs — passport series and number; you also need to specify what exactly the practical necessity of obtaining a consultation consists of, provide factual circumstances, put a signature or QES, and specify the date of the appeal. If these details are missing, an ITC is not provided, and the tax office sends a standard response according to the Law on Citizens' Appeals. (Zir Tax)

The best structure of an appeal for business is as follows: first briefly describe the operation model, then list the essential facts, next name the norm or tax regarding which uncertainty has arisen, and at the end ask 1-3 precise questions. The more specifically the facts are described, the higher the likelihood of obtaining a practically applicable answer. When the situation involves contracts, supply chains, cash on delivery, commission, imports, or excisable goods, it is advisable to present the factual model as detailed as possible, otherwise the tax authority may indicate that the provided information is insufficient for an exhaustive consultation. (Zir Tax)

How to submit an ITC via the Electronic Cabinet

You can submit an appeal via the "Individual tax consultations" menu in the private part of the Electronic Cabinet. In this form, you need to select the STS body, fill in the mailing address, contact phone number, email address, outline the factual circumstances, and the date of submission. Fields with the name and EDRPOU/RNTRC code are filled in automatically. Currently, the field for outlining factual circumstances in this menu is limited to 2000 characters. (if.tax.gov.ua)

If the description of the situation does not fit, it is more practical to use the "Correspondence with STS" menu: there you can select the appeal type "consultation", short content "On providing an individual tax consultation", and attach a scanned appeal with annexes in PDF up to 5 MB. Within one working day after sending, the taxpayer receives an incoming registration number and the registration date of the appeal; further, this information can be viewed in the "Incoming" tab of the "Incoming/outgoing documents" menu. (if.tax.gov.ua)

Terms of providing an ITC

The general term for providing an ITC is 25 calendar days following the day the appeal is received by the controlling body. An authorized person of the central STS body may extend this term, but not by more than 15 calendar days, and they must notify about the extension in writing before the initial term expires. Thus, the usual maximum for an ITC is 40 calendar days from the date of receipt of the appeal. (vin.tax.gov.ua)

However, if the appeal does not meet the requirements for an ITC, the tax office does not issue an ITC, but sends a response as to a regular appeal. The Law of Ukraine "On Citizens' Appeals" applies to such responses: the general term is up to one month, and if the issue does not require additional study — immediately, but no later than 15 days; in exceptional cases, the term can be extended, but overall not exceeding 45 days. (nvp.tax.gov.ua)

A separate special regime applies to taxpayers with a high level of voluntary compliance with tax legislation included in the relevant List. For them, an ITC is provided exclusively by the central body of the STS within 15 calendar days without the possibility of extending the term; if an appeal is mistakenly submitted to a territorial body, it must forward it to the central body no later than the next working day. (nvp.tax.gov.ua)

Unified Register of ITCs and why it is important

A paper or electronic ITC is subject to registration in the Unified Register of Individual Tax Consultations and is placed on the web resource of the STS without the taxpayer's personal data. Access to this register is free and open via the Electronic Cabinet. For business, this is useful for two reasons: firstly, you can verify if your response is indeed registered as an ITC; secondly, you can see the approaches of the STS in similar disputes. But you cannot rely on someone else's ITC as your own protection — it is merely a guideline. (Zir Tax)

What to do after receiving an ITC

After receiving an ITC, it is worth checking whether the tax authority correctly reflected the factual circumstances of your situation. If the response formally quotes the law but does not provide a conclusion regarding your operations, the benefit from such an ITC will be low. For internal business protection, it is desirable to store the ITC together with the appeal itself, attachments to it, contracts, the operation scheme, and the company's internal decision on applying exactly such an approach. During an inspection, this will help show that you acted in good faith, consistently, and within the limits of the provided consultation. (Zir Tax)

For Torgsoft and any business working with mass retail, online sales, acquiring, returns, delivery, software cash registers, and excisable goods, the best strategy is as follows: do not wait for an inspection, but close controversial tax nodes in advance through an ITC specifically for those operations where there is turnover, scale, or reputational risk. This is especially important where a single error can be repeated on hundreds of receipts, invoices, or orders and turn into a systemic risk. (vin.tax.gov.ua)

Can an ITC be appealed

Yes. A taxpayer may appeal an ITC provided to them in paper or electronic form to the court as a legal act of individual action if they believe that it contradicts the norms or content of the corresponding tax or fee. If the court cancels the ITC, the tax office must provide a new consultation taking into account the court's conclusions; the law grants 30 calendar days for this from the day the decision comes into legal force. (if.tax.gov.ua)

A brief example from practice: the review of judicial practice of the Administrative Court of Cassation within the Supreme Court notes that a written or electronic tax consultation can be appealed as an act of individual action; a decision of the Supreme Court dated November 10, 2020, in case No. 826/21951/15 is cited as an example. For business, this means that an ITC is not the "ultimate truth", but a procedural document that can be corrected through the court if the tax authority made a mistake.

Conclusion for the entrepreneur

An ITC should be perceived as a tax security tool, not a formality. It is most useful where you have a real business operation, an ambiguous norm, and a risk of systemic repetition of an error. A well-prepared appeal with a full description of the facts gives the business a much stronger position than oral advice or someone else's consultations from the register. (Zir Tax)

The safest practical route today is as follows: submit an appeal in electronic or paper form, check for the presence of the ITC registration number in the Unified Register, make sure that the conclusion relates specifically to your facts, and only after that build your accounting and operational process on it. Exactly such a sequence best protects business from fines, penalties, and unnecessary disputes with the tax authority. (Zir Tax)

Official sources

Програма обліку товару для інтернет-магазинів, крамниць, торгових точок, складів та виробництва