For learning from professional books, we recommend choosing a format based on the task and whether you can return to details. If you need to check wording or work through diagrams or calculations, prepare the text. If you choose an audiobook, plan for pauses and replaying the passages you need.
The reviewed studies compared specific excerpts and learning presentations. Their results do not establish that one format is universally better for complete business books or for educating Ukrainian entrepreneurs.
What exactly did the studies compare?
In one laboratory experiment, students read popular science excerpts silently, read them aloud, or listened to them. In two samples, memory test results after listening were lower than after reading aloud. At the same time, no statistically significant difference was found between reading aloud and reading silently. This result does not support general advice to always read aloud for better recall.
Another primary study describes two experiments with short health messages. According to the authors’ abstract, in the second experiment, information recall was better after text, while comprehension was similar after reading and listening. Therefore, conclusions need to be tied to a specific measure. Results from short messages do not establish format advantages for an entire professional book.
Why combining text and audio does not have a universal advantage either
In an experiment with multimedia presentations, older participants performed best on the test after narration accompanied by matching text. However, the experiment did not include a “text only” option. It compared narration, narration with matching text, and narration with nonduplicating text and images.
The system set the pace of the presentation. The authors noted that this removed the possibility of reviewing the material by rereading it. Thus, the experiment did not cover ordinary work with a book, when readers can pause and return to an explanation they need. It also does not prove that reading and listening to business books simultaneously is better.
How to choose a format for a work task
We suggest the following order for choosing. This is a practical recommendation, not a result of the experiments described above.
- Prepare the text to check details. If you plan to work through a formula, diagram, or precise definition, make sure you can access the relevant passage and illustrations.
- For listening, check that you can return to a passage. Before starting, choose a way to mark the places you need: a chapter number, timestamp, or short note. Stop the recording when you need to check an explanation.
- Combine formats as needed. You can listen to a chapter and then refer to the text to check a specific example. Do not expect combining formats on its own to automatically improve learning.
How to check whether you understood a chapter
Try this short self-check after reading or listening:
- Put the material aside and state the main conclusion in your own words.
- Write down one action you want to consider for your work. For example, check the conditions for applying the pricing method described.
- Return to the relevant passage. Check your summary, the conditions for applying the method, and its limitations.
- If the explanation is still unclear, reread or replay it before using it.
This is a suggested way to check your own understanding. The studies described did not test the effectiveness of this specific sequence for memory or business outcomes.
Go back to the previous step